Climate History
By Bruce Bartlett
Wednesday, June 27, 2007
Many
people are worried about global warming today. They fear that the polar
ice caps will melt, raising sea levels and creating environmental
chaos. Such concerns are not new. The historical record tells us of
many warming episodes—and subsequent cooling periods—that have
bedeviled humans for thousands of years.
The ancient Greek philosopher Plato, who lived from 427 BC to 347 BC,
wrote about major climate changes that were known in his day. In the
dialogue, “Timaeus,” he argued that global warming occurs at regular
intervals, often leading to great floods. Said Plato, “When…the gods
purge the earth with a deluge of water, the survivors…are herdsmen and
shepherds who dwell on the mountains. But those who…live in cities are
carried by the rivers into the sea.”
In the dialogue, “Critias,” Plato wrote about weather-related
geological changes. He referred to “formidable deluges” that washed
away all the top soil, turning the land into a “skeleton of a body
wasted by disease.” What were now plains had once been covered with
rich soil, Plato said, and barren mountains were once covered with
trees. The yearly “water from Zeus” had been lost, he went on, creating
deserts where the land was once productive.
Plato’s student, Aristotle, who lived from 384 BC to 322 BC, also
recorded evidence of global warming in his work, “Meteorologica.” He
noted that in the time of the Trojan War, the land of Argos was marshy
and unarable, while that of Mycenae was temperate and fertile. “But now
the opposite is the case,” Aristotle wrote. “The land of Mycenae has
become completely dry and barren, while the Argive land that was
formerly barren, owing to the water has now become fruitful.” He
observed the same phenomenon elsewhere covering large regions and
nations.
Theophrastus, a student of Aristotle who lived from 374 BC to 287 BC,
discussed climate change in his work, “De ventis,” which means “The
Wind.” He observed that in Crete, “nowadays the winters are more severe
and more snow falls.” In earlier times, Theophrastus said, the
mountains there bore grain and fruit, and the island was more populous.
But when the climate changed, the land became infertile. In his book,
“De causis plantarum,” Theophrastus noted that the Greek city of
Larissa once had plentiful olive trees, but that falling temperatures
killed them all.
In the first century AD, an ancient Roman named Columella wrote an
agricultural treatise called, “De re rustica.” In it, he discussed
global warming that had turned areas once too cold for agriculture into
thriving farm communities. Columella cites an authority named Saserna
who recorded many such cases. According to Saserna, “regions which
formerly, because of the unremitting severity of winter, could not
safeguard any shoot of the vine or the olive planted in them, now that
the earlier coldness has abated and weather is becoming more clement,
produce olive harvests and the vintages of Bacchus [wine] in greatest
abundance.”
In the Middle Ages, people began recording the temperature and
climate-related phenomena, such as the dates when plants began to
blossom annually. They were aware of a warming trend that began around
900 and a cooling trend that began around 1300. We know that during the
warm period, the Vikings established settlements in Greenland where
perpetual ice had previously covered the land. Ancient Norse records
tell us that these settlements were abandoned after 1250 when falling
temperatures made farming less viable and spreading ice in the sea made
transportation more difficult.
The cooling trend led to heavy rains in 14th century Europe that were
too much for the crops, leading to reduced agricultural output and
numerous famines. In the 15th century, a warming trend returned, which
lasted until the middle of the 16th century when temperatures again
started to fall.
By the 17th century, it was clearly apparent that a cooling trend was
altering sea routes, changing the kinds of crops farmers could grow,
fishing patterns and so on. Glaciers began to advance rapidly in many
places and rivers that had long been ice-free year round started to
freeze in the winter. This “little ice age” continued well into the
19th century. Since then, we have been in a warming cycle that appears
to have accelerated around 1950.
The point of this review is that we know a great deal about climate
changes from the historical record and need not rely solely on
scientific studies of core samples, tree rings and so on. These changes
occurred long before industrialization and could not possibly have been
man-made in any way whatsoever. They don’t prove that man is not now
affecting the climate through carbon dioxide emissions, but they do
tell us that temporary warming trends are common in human history. It
may only be a matter of time before another cooling trend comes along.
Bruce
Bartlett is a former senior fellow with the National Center for Policy
Analysis of Dallas, Texas. Bartlett is a prolific author, having
published over 900 articles in national publications, and prominent
magazines and published four books, including Reaganomics: Supply-Side Economics in Action.
Be the first to read Bruce Bartlett's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.
©Creators Syndicate