More Children Left Behind

| 1 Comment | 0 TrackBacks
Another article in The Economist got me thinking this week. Seems the UK is finding that its young students are not reading as much as they used to. This is not really big news and is an international trend. What was interesting was that in "1997 the government introduced a national literacy strategy" to address this problem. The "rigidly-structured daily one-hour lesson" seems to have actually turned kids off of books (do tell). Students asked why it was good to be able to read answered that it would help them do better on tests, not that reading was enjoyable. This seems to me to be exactly where we are headed with the emphasis in NCLB on standardized testing in reading and math (and soon science, which makes me most nervous). Programs emphasizing mechanics will drain critical literacy skills of inherent richness and leave students even further behind and even less interested in school. I can think of nothing more likely to reduce enjoyment of reading than turning it into a highly-structured mechanical activity.  Is the goal of education to create good factory line workers (a job that is increasingly disspearing), or to produce people with intellectual curiosity and deep love of learning?  Obvious answer, but do we really think that creating highly structured (read as teacher proof) curricula is a way to help people learn?  Seems so, as long as the measure of learning is how well you do on a standardized exam -- and hey, there are lots of those in life, so at least we are preparing them for that.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:

1 Comment

Scott, I couldn't agree more. The thought that kids are turned off to reading b/c it is viewed as a chore is appaling to me. I spent all my summers growing up at a cottage on fishing creek in northeast PA ... not TV at all, just the pictures floating through my head as we read Tom Sawyer, Huck Finn, and so much more. Not sure where I'd be today without an appreciation for reading.

NCLB is a joke -- always has been and always will be. Too bad it is impacting our children the way it is. My sister in law is a teacher and she complains to me about how her lesson plans that were once innovative are now nothing more than memorization activities. It kills her ... imagine what it is doing to our kids.

Leave a comment

Search This Blog

Full Text  Tag

Recent Entries

ETS Talk(back), Part 1
I am a regular listener of ETS talk, a great podcast here at PSU. The most recent episode (issue?) was…
Interview by Cahoy
I am participating with a little experiment that was brought to my attention by my favorite PSU librarian, Ellysa Cahoy.…
My conversation with a gaming master
Recently I had a hallway conversation about "serious games" with a man who takes games seriously. Chris Stubbs, an affiliate…