Forced Overtime can force poor performance, home life
News At Penn State Delaware County
Despite severe personal and professional stresses caused by mandatory
overtime, many employers still continue to demand longer-than-standard
hours from workers in an attempt to reign in immediate costs and
maintain adequate staff, according to a recent study co-authored
by a Penn State researcher.
Lonnie Golden, associate professor of economics at Penn State
Delaware County, and Helene Jorgensen, research associate at the
Center for Economic and Policy Research, found that several industries,
including agriculture, mining, manufacturing, transportation and
communication had 25 percent or more of the workforce working
longer-than-standard hours on a regular basis. Emergency service
and transportation jobs are those most subject to having involuntary
overtime.
The study titled, Time After Time: Mandatory Overtime in the U.S.
Economy, was published this month by the Economic Policy Institute
in Washington, D.C
.
Overtime can cause substandard work and considerable strain on
family balancing, and industry estimates place stress- and fatigue-related
problems brought on by excessive overtime and other factors at
between $150 and $300 billion annually.
"Workers who put in the kind of long hours that go along
with overtime often get less sleep, which can lead to an increase
in workplace accidents and injuries," the authors say. One
of the occupations most affected by mandatory overtime is nursing
in hospitals, where chronic understaffing often leads nurses to
work additional hours in less than ideal physical and emotional
condition. In fact, a national survey of nurses shows that 56
percent believe the time they have for each patient has decreased,
and 75 percent feel that the quality of patient care has decreased
in the last two years
.
"High patient load and fatigue from long hours can result
in inadequate compliance with procedures and less monitoring of
patients. As a result, overtime can compromise quality in patient
care," the authors say. Nurses aren't alone, however, among
hospital workers who feel that working long hours has adversely
affected their performance. Medical residents cited fatigue as
a cause for their serious mistakes in 4 out of 10 cases.
This has led many states to adopt or propose legal limits on mandatory
overtime for nurses and others. Key proposals from the report
for state and federal legislation include:
- *Capping the number of overtime hours that can be required in
a given week.
- Giving employees the right to refuse mandatory overtime, except
in emergencies.
- Reforming the Fair Labor Standard Act's overtime provisions
to cover more, currently "exempt" employees.
- Sanctioning employers who penalize or otherwise discriminate
against employees who refuse to work more than the maximum number
of hours per day or week; and
- Inducing employers who face continuous labor shortages to hire
and train additional employees, rather than require current employees
to put in more hours.
In addition to improving the workers' ability to perform their
job functions, these measures would help workers spend more quality
time at home, and enhance their morale both at home and in the
workplace, the authors say.