Rapid New Understanding of Superconducting
Compound
By KENNETH
CHANG
s a scientific problem, magnesium diboride
turned out to be a pretty easy nut to crack.
In January 2001, Dr. Jun Akimitsu of Aoyama Gakuin
University in Tokyo set off a flurry of research with the
announcement that the substance is a superconductor, able to
convey electricity with virtually no resistance. That was
unexpected because magnesium diboride is a simple, readily
available metallic compound. (No one had thought to check it
for superconductivity before.) And it remains a superconductor
at temperatures about 29 degrees warmer than any other
metal.
Advertisement
"We're red-faced we didn't predict magnesium diboride,"
said Dr. Marvin L. Cohen, a professor of physics at the
University of California at Berkeley.
Now, just a year and a half later, scientists have an
almost complete understanding of the compound's unusual
superconducting abilities. By contrast, physicists took more
than 40 years to come up a theory to explain the first
superconductors discovered in 1911, and the so-called
high-temperature superconductors, discovered in 1986, continue
to befuddle theorists 16 years later.
Magnesium diboride proved easier to solve because it acts
like a traditional superconductor, with a few wrinkles.
Writing in the Aug. 15 issue of Nature, Dr. Cohen and other
scientists at Berkeley reported that starting with the basic
properties of the constituent atoms — magnesium and boron —
they were able to calculate properties of magnesium diboride
that matched what had been observed in experiments, including
the maximum superconducting temperature — minus 389 degrees
Fahrenheit. "Almost right on," said Dr. Steven G. Louie, a
professor of physics at Berkeley and another of the
researchers.
While magnesium diboride cannot superconduct unless it is
much colder than the high-temperature superconductors, it is
much cheaper and easier to work with. Some expect the material
to find use in magnets for magnetic resonance imaging machines
and certain electronic devices that now use low-temperature
superconductors.
The compound's relatively high superconducting temperature
comes from its unique electronic configuration. The boron
atoms line up in honeycomb-shaped layers that resemble chicken
wire — the same structure as graphite — but some of the bonds
between the boron atoms are missing electrons.
In superconductivity, electrons collect into pairs at low
enough temperatures, enabling them to travel without bouncing
off atoms, eliminating electrical resistance. In magnesium
diboride, in addition to the usual current-carrying electrons,
the vacancies in the boron bonds also pair up. The bonds
between the vacancies are especially strong and not as easily
shaken apart by thermal vibrations, allowing the material to
continue superconducting at warmer temperatures.
"I think we understand it quite well," Dr. Louie said.
"Most of the issues have been resolved."
Other scientists had worked out the same basic ideas, but
the Berkeley calculations are the most accurate.
Scientists have also made progress in preparing magnesium
diboride for practical use. Two research groups this week
publish papers on how to fabricate high-quality thin films —
an essential step on the road to constructing electronic
devices. Earlier techniques produced films with rough surfaces
or could not be easily incorporated into processes for
electronic devices where several layers of different materials
need to be built upon each other.
The difficulty is that magnesium does not readily stick to
a surface, preferring to float as vapor.
"If it doesn't stick, there isn't any magnesium," said Dr.
Xiaoxing Xi, a professor of materials science at Pennsylvania
State University. Without magnesium, there is no magnesium
diboride.
Dr. Xi and other scientists at Penn State and the
University of Michigan solved the sticking problem by putting
high-pressure magnesium vapor in the chamber as they make the
films on top of flat sapphire crystals that act as a template.
The vapor keeps the magnesium in the film intact.
The films, less than one hundred-thousandth of an inch
thick, are like almost perfect slices of single crystals. The
results appear in the current issue of the journal Nature
Materials.
"These are remarkably good films made by an extremely
simple, cheap method," said Dr. John M. Rowell, a professor at
Northwestern University, who wrote an accompanying commentary.
"It's probably the easiest way to deposit relatively thick
films."
Researchers at the University of Wisconsin led by Dr.
Chang-Beom Eom, a professor of materials science and
engineering, report similar films made with a different
technique in the current issue of Applied Physics Letters.
They lay down boron atoms first, then heat them in magnesium
vapor at 1,500 degrees. "That reacts, and it forms a
crystalline magnesium diboride," Dr. Eom said.
The hope is that the thin films can be turned into devices
like Josephson junctions, in which a superconducting current
tunnels across a gap for use for ultrafast switches or
sensitive detectors of magnetic fields. Josephson junctions
cannot be consistently and reliably made from high-temperature
superconductors.
Over the past year, scientists have found ways to increase
the amount of current carried by magnesium diboride by about a
factor of 10 and have improved its performance in high
magnetic fields, necessary for applications like magnetic
resonance imaging machines.
A startup company, Hyper Tech Research Inc. in Troy, Ohio,
is experimenting with techniques to make magnesium diboride
wires up to 100 yards in length, and it hopes to extend that
to 1,000 yards sometime next year. Michael Tomsic, president
of Hyper Tech, said the company aimed to start selling wires
in a couple of years.
While researchers have improved magnesium diboride's
current-carrying capacity and resilience to magnetic fields,
the maximum superconducting temperature has not budged from
what Dr. Akimitsu originally reported: minus 389 degrees.
All of the usual tricks — substituting different atoms,
putting it under pressure — have all lowered the temperature,
not raised it. The Berkeley calculations may offer new avenues
for experimentation.
"What we need to do now," said Dr. Louie of Berkeley, "is
be more clever."
Doing research?
Search the archive for more than 500,000
articles:
It's easy to follow the top
stories with home delivery of The New York Times
newspaper. Click Here
for 50%
off.
A thin film of
magnesium diboride grown by Penn State researchers is pure and
smooth enough to be used in future electronic devices. The
bumps are only a few 10-millionths of an inch
high.