Psychology
of Motor Skill Acquisition
SKILL
(Definitions)
Skill
is the integration of well-adjusted muscular performance rather than a
tying together of mere habits (Pear, 1927)
- Skill is both mental and motor; and they are learned
patterns (Bartlett, 1948)
- Skill is a continuum from predominatly habitual
(not required to think) to predominantly perceptual (necessary to
think about) (Knapp, 1961)
- Skill is the process of mastering redundant degrees of
freedom in the moving organ. In other words, it is conversion to a controllable
system (Bernstein, 1967)
- Skill consists in the ability to bring about some end
result with maximum certainty and minimum outlay of energy, or time and
energy (Guthrie, 1972)
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
Early Period (1898-1950)
- Bryan and Hunter - learning curve (nonlinear)
- Book - breathing places or plateaus
- Thorndike's Law of Effect - (1874)
- Learning is an automatic process without intervention of conscious
awareness, unconscious strength training of a habit and connections between
stimulus and response.
- Thorndike's Knowledge of Results (KR)
- declarative vs. procedural
- qualitative vs. quantitative
- augmented (Newell, 1977)
- Woodworth (1898) - transfer of training
Middle Period (1950-1960)
- Motivation and insormation views of KR (Bilodeau, 1959)
- Fitts' (1962) - stages of learning
- Fitts' Law (1954)
- Adams' "closed loop" theory of motor control
- Henry and Rodgers' "open loop" theory
Current Period (1960-Present)
- Bernstein - degrees of freedom problem and coordinative
structure (1967- present)
- Gibson - ecological psychology (1975-present)
- Turvey & Kugler - dynamic system approach (1980-present)
- Nashner's Design
- Preparatory activity examples
- Postural perturbation experiments
NEWELL'S 1977 CONTRIBUTION TO SKILL ACQUISITION
Augmented information is any information that is not naturally
available within the task constraints.
- Information feedback prior to action
- verbal instruction
- demonstration
- Information feedback during the action
- guided practice
- support and motivation while practicing
- Information feedback after the action
- qualitative knowledge of results (KR)
- quantitative knowledge of results (KR)
GENTILE'S 1972 CONTRIBUTION TO SKILL ACQUISITION
CONCEPT OF EFFICIENCY AND SKILL
- Maximum outcome and minimum energy expenditure (Sparrow, 1983)
- mechanical efficiency
- energy demands
- efficient agonist
- antagonist activation
- Efficiency concept
- effortlessness of performance
- mechanical and physiological efficiency
MOTOR CONTROL
- Coordination and control
- experimental psychology; motor skill and motor learning
- neurophysiology; motor control
- Motor program concept
- arguments supporting motor program concept:
- de-afferentation design (Leshley)
- reaction tme design (simple vs. complex)
- feed-forward command in posture
- Nashner's design
- plan program - execution
MOTOR PROGRAM
PROBLEMS WITH THE MOTOR PROGRAM CONCEPT
- Storage of motor programs
- Jasper and Penfeild esperiments
- Novelty of motor tasks
- Bernstein's concept - movement is not completely determined
by effector processes, but also by sensory information from internal and
external sources
- functional non-univocality of connection between central nervous system
and periphery organs
BERNSTEIN'S CONCEPT
- Source of Indeterminacy
- Anatomical
- multiaxial joints, musclular complexity, large number of biomechanical kinematic chains
- Mechanical
- reactive and inertial forces
- interaction effect of different muscles
- Pyhsiological
- selective relationship between central nervous system and periphery
- Phychological
- arousal, anxiety, motivation apprehension, fear, etc.
ADAMS' THEORY
Closed Loop control of movement production
- Environment - Knowlage of Results (KR)
1. Influences response initiation which is the memory
trace mechanism
2. Influences perceptual trace which detects error and corrects
the error
- Central Nervous System - the execution mechanism which
is movement production
1. Affected by the perceptual trace
2. Affected by the response initiation
3. Influences the moving organ
- Moving Organ
1. Detects any errors
2. Sends feedback information to the brain to correct errors in movement
3. Slow movements need more feedback than faster movements
4. Highly skilled actions rely more on the motor programs than less skilled
actions
FITTS' LAW
- Movement phases - initial adjustment and current control
- Movement is a function of distance versus velocity
FITTS' LAW - Revised
- Speed-Accuracy Trade-Off
- Both direction and distance are taken into account
- Movement characteristics
- Types of tasks
- Types of errors
WOODWORTH LEGACY (1954)
Back
Next:
Preparation
Home