I'm pretty sure I'm going to fail at the Blog-A-Day Challenge this month. I'm at a major week-long management training in Maryland this week and I hardly have time to breath let alone type. Wake-Up is 5:30am. Bedtime is midnight... if we're lucky. Project after project.
Thought of day: Embarrassment makes you grow through learning. Kinda reminds me of "tough love."
Accomplishment: I was selected out of 17 students to be the first student division leader... and didn't mess up too terribly bad. Apparently I should go into protocol.
Out.
During the Spring 2009 semester, Matt Jackson required students to submit comments, new entries, and/or course resources to a class blog. These posts were used to determine the class participation portion of the grade for the course. Students were also given the option of creating and maintaining their own blogs (with a minimum of one reflective entry per week) for extra credit.
Thoughts on the Semester:
Logically it makes sense that giving students opportunities to reflect should have some benefits. The challenge in a course this large is when you have 300 people posting comments it becomes a yes/no answer as far as giving points (i.e. Here are 10 points because you posted). But when you look at what students wrote, eight out of ten posts don't say anything. It may not have been wise to give blog prompts to students, as answers were less thoughtful than the open posts in the extra credit blogs. This group blog idea works better in classes where there is a small enough number that the instructor can give individual attention to each post. Ways to make more useful?
At the end of the semester, more than 70 students had completed the extra credit opportunity. The plus side of the extra credit assignment was that it made students maintain their own blog all semester long. Students had to decide and join at the start of semester so they were committed from the start. This eliminated the possibility of students attempting extra credit simply because they were slacking throughout the semester.
Possibilities for the Future:
1. Matt prefers the idea of something that asks the students to dig a little. For example: Here's the topic. Go find an article that deals with the topic, post a link, and give your reaction. A potential problem could be that one person finds an article and others just copy it. Not yet sure how to fix this issue, but students should have to do more while keeping an open dialogue.
2. Every two weeks have an online debate about a class topic. Each person is assigned randomly to a group of around ten. Every group is responsible for arguing one side of one debate. So while twenty students debate, the other groups weigh in on which group they thought did better (or what they did well at). Each group must debate once and critique three other times.
3. What is the potential for using wikis? Are there other large-enrollment courses that are contributing to class wikis?
Questions for Matt
1. Will you use blogs again in FA09?
Matt would still like to use blogs, but probably for extra credit only. For the debate idea, might possibly use ANGEL because it has tools for debate/fishbowls and grading is included.
2. Will you use the textbook again in FA09?
Struggling to decide. Ambition is to eliminate the book. The textbook is useful for the historical background - radio, TV industry, etc. Over the summer Matt would like to find some good chapters on each industry and give out course packets instead. For the other subjects he'd like to use current articles (keeps class information current). This could be a good use for blogs. Post a topic of the week and let students find and post links to current articles and discuss how they relate to the class topics.
ETS Focus Areas for SU09
1. Think of creative ways to make blogs and debates or finding news stories to comment on by each student.
2. How does the Internet work? What should a consumer understand about how the Internet operates, and what should someone wanting to go into the Internet industry know/understand about how it operates? What is important to teach in this section? Web sites, readings, etc. would be useful.
3. Look at each topic listed in the syllabus and suggest activities that correspond.
4. Would like to help students do a better job of understanding how the Internet is structured and therefore the best ways to find/search things online (different kinds of search engines, etc.). Google Scholar?
Recent Comments