At first glance, I was excited to read this article, as it details--at least on the surface--the ongoing commitment to fostering free-choice or constructivist learning in some of the most well-known museums on the planet. As I read; however, it became clear that the opportunities featured in the article are primarily concentrated on art making, offered under the pedagogical auspices of "being in galleries, meeting artists and understanding their world." Furthermore, most of these examples featured art making in physical spaces outside the museum, which is problematic in itself--art museum education has long been relegated to basements and other "fringe" areas of the museum...what does it mean when learning is offered outside the physical space of the museum, i.e., the pop-up center that is soon to open at the Whitney?
As I read, I recalled an interesting comment, made my by colleague and friend Professor Steve Carpenter during a presentation on reconceptualizing curriculum at NAEA. He questioned, ever so briefly, whether or not the act of art making is, in fact, the primary goal/foundation of every model of art education (his question specifically focused on Eco-environmental curriculum)? I wonder...if it is, then where does that leave the myriad other discourses that surround art education and art museum education? What happens when we as professional educators privilege a particular kind of knowing over all other ways of relating to objects in the museum, especially when very few people excel at the skills that are being introduced in these short workshops?
As I read, I recalled an interesting comment, made my by colleague and friend Professor Steve Carpenter during a presentation on reconceptualizing curriculum at NAEA. He questioned, ever so briefly, whether or not the act of art making is, in fact, the primary goal/foundation of every model of art education (his question specifically focused on Eco-environmental curriculum)? I wonder...if it is, then where does that leave the myriad other discourses that surround art education and art museum education? What happens when we as professional educators privilege a particular kind of knowing over all other ways of relating to objects in the museum, especially when very few people excel at the skills that are being introduced in these short workshops?

